When to File an Extension (And When to Run)
Extensions aren’t always bad — but here’s when they help, when they hurt, and how to use them smart.
I’m Patrick Brunk — the tax pro who helps real people use extensions the right way without getting stuck in endless “I’ll handle it later” hell.
An extension can be a smart move if you truly need more time — big life change, missing docs, or complex returns that shouldn’t be rushed. But too many people use extensions as a crutch — and end up paying more in penalties and stress later.
I’ll break down when an extension makes sense, what an extension actually covers (hint: it’s not more time to pay), and the red flags that say it’s better to file now and fix it later.
Extensions Explained — Smart or Slippery?
An extension only gives you more time to file — not more time to pay. It bumps your paperwork deadline from April 15 to October 15.
But if you owe tax, the balance is still due by the April deadline. If you don’t pay, you’ll rack up penalties and interest, extension or not.
Sometimes it’s smart:
- Your documents are late (like K-1s from partnerships).
- You need time to make sure you get every deduction you’re entitled to.
- You switched tax pros and need a clean handoff.
- You’d rather file right than file rushed.
An extension can protect you from costly mistakes if you truly need it.
An extension is not an excuse to procrastinate. Bad reasons:
- Hoping you’ll magically have more money later.
- Kicking the can down the road with no plan to fix missing pieces.
- Avoiding tough choices like paying a big balance due.
Extensions without a plan just grow the mess.
Not technically — but if you owe and don’t pay something with your extension, you’ll rack up penalties for late payment. Smart move: estimate what you owe and pay at least 90% by April to minimize fees.
Very rarely — but yes, if you file it wrong or the data doesn’t match IRS records (like wrong Social Security Number). If your extension is rejected and you don’t fix it quickly, your return is late and penalties kick in. That’s why I double-check every client’s extension.
Nope — there’s no proof an extension itself triggers an audit. But rushed, sloppy returns absolutely do. If more time means a cleaner, accurate return, an extension can actually protect you.
You don’t get multiple bites at the apple — the IRS gives you one automatic six-month extension. After October 15, you’re officially late. If you still don’t file, you’re in late-filing penalty territory (5% per month, up to 25% of the tax due).
File something — even if it’s not perfect — and amend later if needed.
Ask yourself:
📌 Do you have all the info you need to file accurately?
📌 Will rushing mean you miss deductions or screw up the math?
📌 Are you trying to avoid a big payment you can’t afford?
If you’re just procrastinating, run from the extension. File now and face it. If you truly need more time to get it right, file the extension and handle it properly.
✅ Patrick's Bottom Line
Used wisely, extensions buy you breathing room. Used wrong, they just pile up more late fees and stress.
If you’re stuck year after year?
That’s a sign it’s time to fix the system, not keep delaying.
📌 Thinking about filing late? Book your free 30-min call — I’ll tell you if an extension is smart or sloppy, and help you handle it cleanly.Explore Our Tax Playbook
Taxes shouldn’t feel like you need a secret decoder ring.
This library is here to break it all down — no ghosting, no jargon, no excuses.
Whether you run your own business, own rentals, got ghosted by your old CPA, or just want to stop tipping the IRS extra — pick your section, get clear answers, and fix it fast.
👉 Book your free 30-min call — I’ll help you figure out where to start, fix it right, and never ghost you.

Small Business & Self-Employed

Rental Properties & Real Estate

IRS Messes & Catch Up

Smart Tax Moves & Planning
Meet PATRICK
Discover why thousands trust Patrick to fix what big firms ignore.
Patrick built Brunk Tax Solutions to do one thing right: fix tax messes fast, with zero ghosting and real answers you can actually use. From small businesses and landlords to side hustlers and crypto investors — Patrick handles the details himself, no handoffs, no runaround.
👉 Want the truth about your taxes — and someone who’ll fix it fast? You found me.

Patrick R. Brunk, MBA, MAcc, EA
Patrick was the youngest person ever to earn an IRS Enrolled Agent license — just 20 years old — and he’s been untangling tough tax problems ever since. He’s filed thousands of complex returns, rescued frustrated clients stuck in “extension hell,” and built a reputation for honest, fast, no-surprise tax help.
When you hire Patrick, you don’t get ghosted. You get him — start to finish.
No call centers. No trainees. Just clear advice, fast action, and real results — every time.